home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=93HT1009>
- <title>
- 52 Election: Primaries:Closer Than Ever
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1952 Election
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- May 5, 1992
- REPUBLICANS
- Closer Than Ever
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p> The Republican presidential contenders were pounding hard
- around the far turn last week, and the race was closer than ever.
- Bob Taft's strategy had been to leap into the lead at the post,
- and stay well ahead. Ike Eisenhower had started slowly, but had
- gained steadily after he settled down to run in earnest. Now, for
- the first time, the general was just about neck & neck with the
- Senator in the only statistic that really counts: the number of
- committed delegates.
- </p>
- <p> Chipping & Corralling. The closeness of the race was
- something of a triumph for both sides. Despite the great, popular
- groundswell that rolled up for Ike in New Hampshire, New Jersey
- and Minnesota, Taft had rolled up most of the delegates in
- Wisconsin, Illinois and Nebraska. But the Eisenhower forces had
- inched out important gains that upset the Taft organization's
- neat plan for early victory. That bloc of 500 delegates from
- three Taft strongholds--the Midwest, the South, and the Mountain
- States--plus more than 100 scattered reinforcements from other
- parts of the country. The Eisenhower forces chipped away some of
- Taft's Midwest bloc, e.g., Iowa, 15 for Ike, nine for Taft,
- corralled some delegates in the Mountain States, and were
- applying the Eisenhower brand of solvent to Taft's Solid South.
- </p>
- <p> Candidate Eisenhower's biggest single gain in delegates came
- last week when New York's district delegates were picked. The
- gain was expected, since Ikeman Tom Dewey controls the New York
- G.O.P. organization. But the figures were still impressive: 73
- for Ike, one for Taft, 16 in doubt. In nine clear-cut contests
- between pledged delegate candidates, Ike won eight, Taft one.
- </p>
- <p> For the next month, the race will continue to be close.
- Ohioan Taft will make some important gains when his home state
- names its 56 delegates May 6. But Ike will be picking up
- delegates along the way, too. Neither candidate is likely to jump
- into a commanding lead until four big, key delegations begin to
- get into line. The four: Pennsylvania (70), Michigan (46), Texas
- (38), and California (70).
- </p>
- <p> Confusing & Varied. In Pennsylvania last week, General
- Eisenhower won another popular victory. He ran away with
- Pennsylvania's presidential preference primary, polling 847,420
- votes, the most any candidate ever got in a Pennsylvania primary.
- Bluff Senator Jim Duff was the state's only big Republican in
- public support of Eisenhower, and the machine of former senator
- Joseph R. Grundy was solid against him. But Ike ran 31,000 votes
- ahead of Senator Ed Martin, who won renomination with the zealous
- support of all the regular G.O.P. organization. In eight head-on
- tests, the voters elected six Ike-pledged delegates, only two for
- Taft.
- </p>
- <p> Despite the Eisenhower victory, however, only seven of
- Pennsylvania's delegates could be firmly counted for Ike. Two
- were for Taft (who got a record 172,829 write-in votes in the
- preference poll), and the rest had to be listed as uncommitted.
- Reason: the presidential preference vote is just "eyewash" to the
- Pennsylvania politicos. The key man now is Governor John S. Fine,
- who will control 32 of the delegates. He wasn't saying where his
- votes will go, but he did not seem overly impressed by the
- primary result. Said he: "Election returns speak what partisans
- desire to read into them. Many of the answers are as confusing as
- they are varied."
- </p>
- <p> Confidence & Doubt. In Michigan, only 13 of the 46 delegates
- are solidly committed (seven for Eisenhower, six for Taft). But
- in Texas, where delegates will be chosen at a state convention
- May 27, and in California, where the delegation is still in Earl
- Warren's pocket, Eisenhower supporters struck one shrewd blow
- last week. H.J. (Jack) Porter, head of the Eisenhower-for-
- President Club of Texas, said he wrote Ike asking him whether he
- favors "state or federal ownership of the `tidelands.'" Ike's
- reply (which pleased oil-rich Texas and California alike): "Once
- again, I agree with the principle that federal ownership in this
- case, as in others, is one that is calculated to bring about
- steady progress toward centralized ownership and control, a trend
- which I have bitterly opposed."
- </p>
- <p> With the race in balance and the first ballot at the
- national convention only ten weeks away, both sides were
- outwardly confident. The Taft forces held firm to their
- prediction of 650 first-ballot votes, 47 more than enough for
- nomination. Said Henry Cabot Lodge, Ike's campaign manager:
- "We're in striking distance of the first ballot." But in spite of
- these calm expressions of confidence, the wise politicians on
- both sides knew that the big breaks ahead could still throw the
- race either way.
- </p>
- <p>Ruckuses & Rump Sessions
- </p>
- <p> In Colorado, Bob Taft's supporters swore that he would get
- at least twelve of the state's 18 delegates to the National
- Convention. Just to nail everything down, Taft's good friend
- Senator Eugene D. Millikin went home from Washington to speak up
- for Bob. The roof blew off before Millikin could raise a hammer.
- Eisenhower supporters under Governor Dan Thornton stormed the
- precinct and county caucuses, went on to take control of the
- district and state conventions. Last week the Ike supporters
- courteously permitted Millikin a place on the delegation, but
- rang up a solid victory for Eisenhower. The final count: Ike 15,
- Taft two, Harold E. Stassen one.
- </p>
- <p> Other convention results of the week:
- </p>
- <p>-- In Georgia, the officially recognized Republican faction
- took a chink out of Taft's Southern armor in ten district
- conventions. Results: ten delegates for Ike one for Taft, one for
- Warren, one uncommitted.
- </p>
- <p>-- In Louisiana, where Eisenhower supporters tried to
- outmaneuver the pro-Taft party leaders, Republicans split wide
- open and wound up in a whole series of rump sessions. Best
- pattern that could be drawn out of the post-convention confusion:
- eight delegates in dispute, two for Taft conceded by Eisenhower
- forces, five for Ike not disputed but not yet conceded by the
- Taft men.
- </p>
- <p>-- In Utah, Republicans met in the Rainbow Randevu, on Salt
- Lake City's South Main Street, argued so long over state
- convention procedure that votes were still being counted when the
- big Saturday-night dance started. While the band played Be My
- Life's Companion, the result was announced: 14 delegates down the
- line for Taft.
- </p>
- <p>-- In Minnesota, Republican leaders of the Third and Fifth
- Congressional districts, which were carried by Ike's spectacular
- primary write-in vote, met and confirmed the results: four
- delegates for Ike. Previous winner of Minnesota's 24 other
- delegate votes: Harold Stassen.
- </p>
- <p>-- In Arizona, Taft men wanted the state delegation
- committed to the unit rule, and the Eisenhower forces rebelled.
- When the argument tied the state convention in parliamentary
- knots, Pro-Taft Author Clarence Budington Kelland, national
- committeeman, seized the microphone and roared: "This convention
- is approaching a point of absurdity. It is a completely
- ridiculous mess. I move to get out of this mess that we adjourn."
- Finally, the convention abandoned the unit rule, did about what
- it was expected to: ten delegates for Taft, two for Eisenhower,
- two uncommitted.
- </p>
- <p>-- In Arkansas, where senator Taft himself keynoted the
- state convention, the delegates followed the keynoter: seven for
- Taft, one for Eisenhower, three uncommitted.
- </p>
- <list>
- <l>DEMOCRATS</l>
- <l>Duel in the South</l>
- </list>
- <p> On a grey afternoon last week, 150 police motorcycles popped
- and putted along Atlanta's downtown Peachtree Street. Behind
- them, in a red bus bearing the hopeful sign "White House,
- Washington, D.C.," a high-school band tootled Dixie. More than
- 250,000 Georgians, lined along the city's sidewalks and gazing
- out of windows, applauded as a hawk-beaked man in a blue Cadillac
- convertible smiled and waved his white Panama hat. It was
- Georgia's own Senator Dick Russell, the Southern Democrat's
- choice, come home to start his campaign for the Democratic
- presidential nomination.
- </p>
- <p> That night, 3,400 Southerners paid $50 apiece to squeeze
- into four dining rooms of the Atlanta Biltmore Hotel for Dick
- Russell's opening campaign fund dinner. Georgia's Governor Herman
- Talmadge and three neighboring governors--South Carolina's James
- F. Byrnes, Florida's Fuller Warren and Mississippi's Hugh White--were on hand. There were delegations from Louisiana, Texas and
- Alabama. It was an impressive launching of the S.S. Southern
- Democrat, 1952.
- </p>
- <p> Characteristic & Dry. Dick Russell drifted through the
- dining rooms soberly clad in black shoes and a neat dark blue
- suit. Then he took his place at one of the three head tables to
- deliver a characteristic speech, dry but sensemaking, warning
- against Government waste, defending states' rights and condemning
- corruption. He had to cut out his sharpest debating point because
- radio and television time was running out, and he didn't get to
- make it until a press conference two days later. The argument: he
- is the only Democratic candidate who can beat Eisenhower because
- he can carry the South. Said Russell: "With 148 electoral votes in
- the 13 states, I only need to get 118 from the other 35 states...." (Russell was using old figures. As a result of the 1950
- census, the 13 states suffered a net loss of two electoral votes,
- now have 146.)
- </p>
- <p> The next day, Russell flew across the border into Florida
- to get down to urgent business. In Florida's May 6 presidential
- popularity contest--and in a second election 21 days later to
- choose Florida's 24 delegates--Russell is pitted against the
- current Democratic primary champ himself, Tennessee's Estes
- Kefauver.
- </p>
- <p> Four Blocks Away. Russell lost no time in taking aim at
- Estes' coonskin cap. Said he: "I understand my opponent has been
- here and addressed you...He's a member of the Armed Services
- Committee of which I am chairman. He is more fortunate than I in
- being able to stay away from Washington to present his candidacy.
- I have not been able to do that because I have certain specific
- legislative responsibilities...We would have been glad to
- have him with us to work...on important matters..."
- </p>
- <p> Russell took note of the Kefauver campaign methods. "I have
- noticed my opponent in the role of underdog. He has referred to
- the machine being against him...He is doing pretty well with
- his operation. I read where he has twelve rooms in a hotel four
- blocks from the White House. I hope that's as close as he gets..."
- </p>
- <p> Russell challenged Kefauver to a winner-take-all bet on the
- Florida primary, kept hammering away at Kefauver's sponsorship of
- Atlantic Union: "It will be a blow to the cause of liberty around
- the world to submerge the sovereignty of the U.S. with other
- nations." On his first day, Russell spoke to 7,500 in
- Gainesville, Ocala, Leesburg and Orlando, finished with a bright
- pink case of sunburn on his bald head. He planned 30 speeches in
- ten days.
- </p>
- <p> The Governor Was Out. Dick Russell knew he was up against
- some tough competition. Kefauver, the man with few delegates but
- plenty of popular victories behind him, had already trudged
- through a good part of Florida with hand extended, and would be
- back again this week.
- </p>
- <p> In Tallahassee, he marched into the state capitol to shake
- the hand of Governor Warren, who has been feuding with Kefauver
- ever since the Senate Crime Investigating Committee brought out
- some embarrassing facts about the political connections of
- gamblers in Florida. The governor just happened to be out. When
- Estes heard that a former Florida National Guard chief had
- refused to attend a Kefauver house rally, he was on the man's
- doorstep at 7 a.m. He was invited in, and talked over coffee for
- almost an hour. Said his startled host: "he almost convinced me."
- </p>
- <p> Kefauver called in his 81-year-old father for a handshaking
- tour, and Illinois' Senator Paul Douglas flew down for some
- speeches. Watching this duel in the South, most politicians and
- reporters agreed that the odds favored Dick Russell. He is the
- regular Southern Democrat; he has powerful organization support
- (from Governor Warren, Florida's full congressional delegation);
- he was drawing bigger crowds than Kefauver. But the experts were
- beginning to get a little leary of quoting the odds when Estes
- Kefauver is running.
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-